Login / Register
  • Donate
  • Get involved
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • History
      • Inner Transition
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Initiatives
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Practical projects
      • Translations
      • Municipalities Project
    • Reconomy
    • Inner Transition
    • Events and Trainings
  • News and blog

    News and Blog

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Guest Editors
    • Community
    • Climate Change
    • Transition initiatives
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • History
      • Inner Transition
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Initiatives
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Practical projects
      • Translations
      • Municipalities Project
    • Reconomy
    • Inner Transition
    • Events and Trainings
  • News and blog

    News and Blog

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Guest Editors
    • Community
    • Climate Change
    • Transition initiatives
  • Home
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • History
      • Inner Transition
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Initiatives
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Practical projects
      • Translations
      • Municipalities Project
    • Reconomy
    • Inner Transition
    • Events and Trainings
  • News and blog

    News and Blog

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Guest Editors
    • Community
    • Climate Change
    • Transition initiatives

Inner City Inclusion

By Catrina Pickering 6th January 2011

Danielle Cohen, Transition Town Stoke Newington

One evening in November 2009 a Transition Town Stoke Newington social was in full swing. Meanwhile, just streets away, a young man was murdered. The tragedy reminded me once again that we were struggling to broaden Transition’s relevance and appeal. TTSN’s relationship with the community and my position within that became an urgent inquiry for me.

Like many inner-city neighbourhoods, Stoke Newington experiences continued waves of migration and gentrification. It is in Hackney, one of the most diverse – and economically deprived – boroughs in London. In the seven years I’ve lived here I’ve often suspected that although it is becoming gentrified (partly, no doubt, by incomers like myself), it remains divided. Expensive clothes shops and organic cafes are juxtaposed with Turkish and Kurdish social clubs and ‘pound shops’. I wanted to explore how Transition, with its emphasis on building community, might tackle this reality.

As my inquiry unfolded through interviews with Transitioners, workshops at the Transition conference and a collaborative research group within TTSN, I became increasingly uncomfortable that for many of us inclusion was about ‘what we [as Transition] want from people, or us trying to co-opt them into our thing’. I was hearing little about how to achieve genuine two-way engagement. There was scant acknowledgement that hierarchical power dynamics might exist between relatively well-educated, mainly white and middle-class Transitioners and the people they were talking about including. Inclusion meant ensuring Transition Initiatives were open, accessible, attractive and welcoming to newcomers and proactively identifying and targeting particular ‘communities’. While all these things are no doubt crucial to inclusion, the implicit aim was to achieve a diversity of people in the movement, often implying converting or assimilating an ‘other’ people or community to ‘our’ Transition way: morally or intellectually superior to ‘theirs’.

Social inequality, and the power dynamics that result from it, can only be tackled if they are first acknowledged. That is why I believe it is vital that as Transitioners we remain open to questioning whether the inclusive Transition we envisage is the right one to pursue. I would argue that some visions of inclusion risk implying and perpetuating hierarchical power relationships, as they can be unwittingly underpinned by assumptions of assimilation and integration. As one of my co-inquirers in the TTSN inclusion group put it, Transition should perhaps not be seeking to include others but should be seeking to be included by them. The challenge, then, for individuals, for TIs and for the movement is to find a way of being open and encouraging diversity without defining the people we seek to include as ‘others’, perpetuating social stratification, denying inequality or claiming superiority.

This article is based on an MSc thesis, ‘Reaching out for resilience’, which can be found at www.inclusivetransition.wordpress.com

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share

Related content

How do we collaborate to bring about Transition at a municipal level?

NEWS

Municipalities in Transition believe that the area represent...

Read more

Get our latest news and updates

Municipalities in Transition

Municipalities in Transition

Our future depends on collaboration. Municipalities are starting to join the global movement for change.

Find out more

Get news and updates

This website is hosted Green - checked by thegreenwebfoundation.org

Transition basic

  • Our Trainers
  • How to start

Get in touch

  • Contact us
  • Press and PR

Support us

  • Donate
  • Buy Stuff
Get involved

© 2021 Transition Network | Company no.6135675 | Charity no.1128675

  • Site Help & Accessibility
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Community Guidelines

This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site you are agreeing to the use of cookies.