Transition Network Logo
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Login / Register
  • Donate
  • Get involved
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • Characteristics
      • History
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Groups
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Inner Transition
      • Framing Inner Transition
      • The history of Inner Transition
      • Inner at a personal level
      • Personal Resilience Resources
      • Conflict Resilience Resources
      • Inner at a group level
      • Inner at the level of the movement
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Municipalities Project
      • Translations
      • Schools in Transition
      • Reconomy
    • Events and Trainings
  • News

    News

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Community
    • Guest Editors
    • Climate Change
    • Politics
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • Characteristics
      • History
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Groups
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Inner Transition
      • Framing Inner Transition
      • The history of Inner Transition
      • Inner at a personal level
      • Personal Resilience Resources
      • Conflict Resilience Resources
      • Inner at a group level
      • Inner at the level of the movement
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Municipalities Project
      • Translations
      • Schools in Transition
      • Reconomy
    • Events and Trainings
  • News

    News

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Community
    • Guest Editors
    • Climate Change
    • Politics
  • Home
  • About the Movement

    About the movement

    Read more

    • What is Transition?
      • Research
      • Why
      • Principles
      • Characteristics
      • History
      • REconomy
    • Who is involved?
    • Transition Hubs Group
    • The Charity
      • Purpose
      • People
      • Transparency
    • How we work
      • Shared governance
      • TN Culture
  • Transition Near me

    Transition near me

    Read more

    • Groups
    • Hubs
  • Stories

    Stories of Transition

    Stories from around the movement ....

    View all stories

    • Meet Transitioners
  • Do Transition

    Do Transition

    Find everything here that you need to develop Transition in your community.

    Read more

    • Starting Transition
      • 7 Essential Ingredients
      • The Essential Guide to Doing Transition
      • How to start
      • Moving to a Core Group
      • In your University
    • Inner Transition
      • Framing Inner Transition
      • The history of Inner Transition
      • Inner at a personal level
      • Personal Resilience Resources
      • Conflict Resilience Resources
      • Inner at a group level
      • Inner at the level of the movement
    • Training
      • Host a training
      • Our Trainers
    • Healthcheck
    • Transition in action
      • Municipalities Project
      • Translations
      • Schools in Transition
      • Reconomy
    • Events and Trainings
  • News

    News

    News, blogs, happenings from in and around the network.

    Browse all

    Popular Categories

    • Blog
    • News
    • Community
    • Guest Editors
    • Climate Change
    • Politics

Peter Ruczynski, Transition Reading on not including inequality in the Transition Network purpose statement

By Catrina Pickering 22nd September 2011

Proposed purpose statement:  “Transition Network supports community-led responses to climate change, inequality and shrinking supplies of cheap energy, building resilience and happiness.”

Who proposed this and why

Adding the single word ‘inequality’ to the wording of the Transition mission is only a small change and, if read fairly quickly, will most probably not register with most people immediately.

For me, the addition of that single word completely changes the face of the Transition movement.  At the moment, there is a level of inequality addressing which I think should occur as a natural part of what we do and want to achieve.  By making it explicit, it becomes something which perhaps can be tackled separately and consequently may dilute the aims of a group or take them in a different direction.  A good coordinator will ensure that it is a part of what the group is trying to achieve but I can also see some groups where this becomes a more major part of what they are trying to do.  I know from personal experience that it’s sometimes hard to keep people focused on the energy and resilience aspects of transition, is it wise to add yet another aspect for people to try and keep in the back of their minds when working on projects?  I believe that everything a group does should be related to the Transition mission and understand how it links into that, this could make that task harder in some ways.

If the word ‘inequality’ is going to be included then there must be a very comprehensive explanation of what it means and, most importantly, how it fits in within the context of the rest of the Transition mission.  At the moment I am finding the fit of that word rather awkward and cannot really see what more people would be expected to do to warrant making it explicit but then, I have not yet seen a comprehensive explanation.

Just to complicate matters, although I may seem rather reticent in my above comments, I do understand the value of the addition and in a broader sense agree with what I think Transition Network is trying to say by the addition of that word.  I attended the talk by Nicole Foss at Henley not long ago and some of the scenarios she painted were scary to say the least.  If, by the addition of that word, Transition Network is thinking about the social implications of peak oil, or more accurately the associated economic consequences and the social problems that will arise from those, then I agree that this is a worthy thing to incorporate.  My concern is will groups really understand this?  Also, the word effectively introduces a more political aspect to the Transition mission, it will be interesting to see how that works out.

At the moment, I feel Transition has a clear set of goals and has mostly (as far as I can tell) resulted in groups that have acted jointly with communities and authorities to achieve the aims that the members of the collective have set out.  By introducing a political aspect to the mission, albeit unintentionally, I feel you stand to lose the clarity of that message, lose some level of cooperation from authorities but gain a social aspect to the movement which is currently, as you yourselves have noticed, there but not addressed.

It’s a tough choice and, judging by the discussions going on on your web site, a choice that will have wide ramifications depending on how people interpret your intentions.  I hope my thoughts have helped you in some small way.
It’s a tough choice and, judging by the discussions going on the web site, a choice that will have wide ramifications depending on how people interpret the intentions of Transition Network.  I hope my thoughts have helped in some small way.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share

Related content

How do we collaborate to bring about Transition at a municipal level?

NEWS

Municipalities in Transition believe that the area represent...

Read more

Get our latest news and updates

Municipalities in Transition

Municipalities in Transition

Our future depends on collaboration. Municipalities are starting to join the global movement for change.

Find out more

Get news and updates

This website is hosted Green - checked by thegreenwebfoundation.org

Transition basic

  • Our Trainers
  • How to start

Get in touch

  • Contact us
  • Press and PR
  • Facebook Twitter YouTube

Support us

  • Donate
  • Buy Stuff
Get involved

© 2023 Transition Network | Company no.6135675 | Charity no.1128675

  • Site Help & Accessibility
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Complaints

This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site you are agreeing to the use of cookies.